Lecture 3: Moving West

Objectives for this week

 

I: History painting/Leutze (continued)

 

II: Manifest Destiny (continued)

 

III: Myths and realties of western settlement

 

IV: The Frontier

 

V: Viticulture (Erica Hannickel)

I: History painting: LeutzeÕs Westward the Course of Empire Takes its Way (1861)

Aka ÒWestward Ho!Ó

Commissioned in 1860 by the Congress for U.S. Capitol Building

Rockies

Golden Gate

culmination of LeutzeÕ pictorial cycle of history paintings

Bishop BerkeleyÕs poem:

In happy climes, the seat of innocence,

Where nature guides and virtue rules,

Where men shall not impose for truth and sense

The pedantry of courts and schoolsÉ

Westward the course of empire takes its way

The four first Acts already past

A fifths shall close the Drama with the day;

TimeÕs noblest offspring is the last

 

Boone (ÒColumbus of the WoodsÓ) in medallion on lower left

II: Manifest Destiny

Origins of the phrase

John L. OÕSullivan, editorial in the Democratic Review (1845)

Mexican War, 1846-8

III: Myths and realties of western settlement

Farming or settling?

Yeoman ideal

farming vs settling (Jasper)

Has the Iowa landscape been shaped by farming or by settling?

Is LeutzeÕ painting a celebration of farming or settling?

Populists or speculators?

Andrew Melrose, Westward, the Star of Empire (1867)

Gooden, ÒPitching Tents in IowaÓ (1857)

 

Settlers and Indians

Is LeutzeÕs painting a peaceful depiction?

Black Hawk

Sauk

Rock River, Illinois

Keokuk

Autobiography, 1833

What are his complaints?

How attached were his people to the land?

How did they try to persuade Blackhawk to move to Iowa?

Was Blackhawk right to stay in Illinois?

Why do you think the autobiography was so popular?

 

Women out west

Jasper on womenÕs unwillingness to uproot

Role of women in LeutzeÕs mural?

Actual role of women on the Overland Trail

Why does GastÕs painting represent the westward movement in the figure of a woman?

African-Americans out west

In the final version of the mural, Leutze added an African-American.

(Support for Emancipation? Or did he, like OÕSullivan, see the West as a safety-valve to expel freed slaves?)

IV: The Frontier

Turner thesis

United States Census Report of 1890

WorldÕs Columbian Exposition, Chicago, 1893

Crash of May 1893

What does the frontier look like? Metaphors? Images?

When does a frontier close?

Is he pessimistic or optimistic about the future course of US history?

Is he right to emphasize the frontier?

Persistence of fascination with frontier into the 20C

JFKÕs ÒNew FrontierÓ

 

 

V: Viticulture (presentation by Erica Hannickel)

Viticulture in America 1840-1870

"drink of civilization"

"Bacchus America--The Old Wine God and the New" (1869)

William R. Prince

"grape fever"