|
Mary Swander, a renowned
poet and professor of English at Iowa State University
gave the following keynote address in celebration
of Humanities Iowa Day in March of 2000.
The Importance
of Poetry in Everyday Life
By Mary Swander
It was a cold, blustery
late March evening, with just enough of a hint of
spring in the air to turn the melting snow to slushy
patches of ice. I was getting over a bad case of
the flu and battling a lingering cough that sent
me into spasms of hacking and sputtering. From Ames,
Iowa, I was driving up 1-35 to Clear Lake to lead
a discussion of Elizabeth Bishop's poetry at the
Public Library. I'd had a busy teaching day and
the hour and half drive seemed never-ending. I kept
pulling into rest stops to swig from my bottle of
cough syrup. Would I make it through this night?
I wondered.
When I arrived at the library,
five or six women in their sixties and seventies
gathered around a table in the basement. The women
seemed reserved, lifeless. Maybe someone was paying
them to be here, too, I thought. After brief introductions
by the librarian, I set up the VCR and showed a
video of Elizabeth Bishop's life. There were shots
of her childhood in Maine, the ocean crashing and
hammering the craggy, rugged Maine shoreline. There
were shots of her life in Brazil, the majesty of
her house, the flora and fauna of the rainforests,
the brightly- colored exotic birds perching in the
dew-covered trees.
I glanced out at
my class. They watched politely, expressionless.
One woman in a pale blue dress closed her eyes,
appearing to doze. This is going to be a long night,
I thought, taking another gulp from my bottle. The
video came to an end. I lectured for about ten minutes
on Bishop's style, the reaction of critics to her
work, her place in American poetry. Now, two more
women were beginning to nod off. I passed out some
Xeroxed copies of several of Bishop's poems. We
read through them. Then in hoarse and strained voice,
I began reciting Bishop's villanelle, "The One Art."
The art of losing isn't
hard to master;
some things seem filled
with the intent
to be lost that their
loss is no disaster.
The poem begins quietly, speaking
of loss in an oblique, almost off hand way. Next,
the poet writes of the fluster of losing common
place things like her keys and how we accept these
moments into our everyday lives. As we age, loss
accelerates. Tangible sentimental things, like your
mother's watch or a house are harder to lose, but
still can be managed, especially compared to losing
cities, rivers, whole continents. In the final,
ironic stanza, the poet maintains her tone of dismissal
of loss. At the same time, she has to almost force
herself to confront the overwhelming feelings of
grief she experienced at the loss of a loved one.
Even losing you (the joking voice, a gesture
I love) I shan't have lied. It's evident
the art of losing's not
too hard to master
though it may look like (Write it!) like
disaster.
There was a long silence
after my reading.
"All right," I finally said.
"Let's just go around the table and get a little
reader response. Tell me what your emotions were,
what was going through your head when I recited
this poem." I called on the woman in the blue dress,
trying to wake her up.
"Well, this poem made me
mad," she said.
That's a weird response.
Sad, maybe, but mad? "This poem made you angry?"
I said.
"Madder than tar," the woman
said, her voice rising a few decibels.
"Could you tell me more
about that?"
"Yes. " She leaned forward
on the table. "This poem completely captures what
it means to grieve. I lost my husband last year
after fifty years of marriage and I was sent all
sorts of greeting cards and condolences and nothing,
nothing, says it the way this poem does."
"I understand," I said.
"I'm sorry to hear about your husband. But you said
that the poem made you angry...
"That's right," the blue
dress said. "I'm mad, just livid that no one, no
teacher or preacher or anyone showed me these beautiful
poems before. I'm seventy years old and I've gone
all my life without knowing Elizabeth Bishop. That
makes me mad! And what's more, you didn't need to
show us that video. I can imagine all those scenes
from the poems themselves. I just shut my eyes when
that film came on. I didn't want it to interfere
with what I'd already created in my own head."
Immediately, the class broke
into a lively and vigorous discussion of the poems
themselves. They related the verse to their own
lives, their families, their work on the farm in
Iowa---so far removed from Bishop's worlds--but
so close to common human experience. Our conversation
dashed from one poem to another, trying to discover
as much as we could in the short time we had. The
librarian even rushed out and hunted through the
stacks for the very issue of the National Geographic
magazine that Bishop mentions in "The Waiting
Room." Although not schooled in some of the more
formal aspects of the poetry and criticism, these
readers were right on target with their genuine,
down-to-earth, direct and intelligent responses
to the work.
On the drive home, I thought
about how wrong I'd been on the journey up to Clear
Lake, how after all these years of reading and writing
poetry, I could still underestimate its value in
the lives of every day people. Sometimes, I think
that we, the reading public, so often hear that
adage that no one really cares about poetry that
we begin to believe it ourselves. And while I do
think it takes some serious study to be able to
appreciate all the nuances and allusions of a complicated
text, it is good to remind myself, that a group
of farm women in northern Iowa can nail the heart
and basic meaning of a poem just as well as the
most schooled critics.
The woman in the blue dress
found a poem on a plain, Xeroxed piece of paper
that comforted her in a way, that brought her emotional
solace in a form that no commercial product could.
While driving south, I remembered another incident
from years before in Burlington, Iowa, that startled
me into a different awareness of the importance
of poetry in every day life. This time in the life
of a ten year old girl.
I was teaching in the Artist-in-the-Schools
program through the Iowa Arts Council in the early
1980s, spending a week's residency in Burlington.
I came into a fourth grade class as I had so many
times that year with a worn copy of Howard Norman's
translation of the Swampy Cree Indian trickster
tales called the Wishing Bone Cycle. The
poems are short and lively.
Crow
sit down shut up
can' t you see
who's sleeping?
It's her
just born
and not ready
to hear your crow noises
yet.
Sit down
shut up.
The students in Burlington readily
understood the sense of play the poem engendered.
Like the farm women, the fourth graders could instantly
engage their imaginations, picturing the scene of
a crow outside in a tree making a huge racket with
a frustrated father inside trying to rock his baby
to sleep. Many of the students had younger brothers
and sisters and could relate to the event from their
own experiences. Did the fourth graders understand
the deeper meaning of the metaphor of the crow noises
and why the innocent daughter wasn't ready for them
yet? Of course not. And I didn't attempt to explain.
We were working on the language level of poetry
and enjoying the magic of what words could do.
The fourth graders jumped
right into writing poems of direct address of their
own. They wrote poems to their dogs, cats, goldfish,
to bicycles, sneakers, and school lockers. They
waved their hands in the air, longing to be the
first to come up in front of the class and read
their creations out loud.
A girl in pigtails fixed
her gaze on me, her deep brown eyes intense and
focused.
I called on her to be first.
She stepped up to the front
of the classroom and began to read. The rest of
the class let out a gasp. I couldn't figure out
what was happening. I glanced to the back of the
room at the regular classroom teacher but she just
stood there, her eyes wide.
The girl in pigtails read
her poem in a clear, strong voice. The whole class
hung on her every word. When she finished, the students
burst into applause. I clapped along with the rest
but didn't grasp the significance of the moment
until the class was over and the teacher pulled
me aside and said, "Do you know that that girl in
pigtails has never, ever in her life talked in class,
never opened her mouth? We didn't know if she was
autistic or what. Now you come in and read poetry
and she jumps up and volunteers to read in front
of everyone!"
Again, the power of poetry
amazed me. There was something so commanding, so
alluring in the language of the poetry of Native
Americans with their oral tradition that stirred
this young girl who had never articulated a sound
to speak. Here was a girl who spoke her first words
in class inspired by a poem that said, "Sit down
and shut up." Surely, there had to be something
more at work than just word fun and games. Just
as Elizabeth Bishop gave voice to the emotions of
the farm women, the Swampy Cree allowed a silent
girl to find her own voice. People connected across
cultures from Iowa to Brazil, from Burlington to
Lake Winnipeg. People found in poetry a means of
expression that had never been presented to them
before. Their lives changed.
So what good is poetry?
It doesn't make money. No, but what good is money
in comforting the grief of a bereft widow or overcoming
the deep fear of a traumatized child? Historically,
poetry, the mother of all other literary genres,
has had more basic roles. In the Middle Ages, poetry
was song, the music sung by the troubadours who
wandered the countryside strumming their lutes and
spreading the news of the land. Poetry had rhyme
and rhythm and was easy to remember. Poetry lent
itself to conveying the great romances of courtly
love. Poetry lent itself to dance and other art
forms, to ballads that retold the common dramas
of the common folk. Poetry cut through class, gender,
and race barriers. Every culture has its chants,
its litanies that re-enforce ritual, that create
forms of worship, that shape custom and culture.
While poetry connects people across cultures, it
also provides the glue within a culture.
In her collection of essays
entitled Why History Matters, the historian
Gerda Lerner writes of her separation from her sister
during the Holocaust in Europe. The Lerners were
from an assimilated, Jewish family in Vienna. Life
was safe, secure, until the Nazis swept through
Austria. The Lerners were separated and forced to
flee for their lives. Cerda made it to America where
she painstakingly learned English in hopes of becoming
a writer. Her sister fled to Great Britain where
she too soon learned the language and took up a
new life.
In the 1950s, the two Lerner
sisters were at long last reunited. But the meeting
was strained. Now the women were coming together
from two different continents, two different cultures,
two different identities. They spoke to each other
in English, their mutual adopted language, but their
dialects were very different and didn't serve to
strengthen their bond. They parted with an uneasy
feeling but vowed to see each other again.
In a couple of years, they
made another attempt to spend time with each other.
This time, the tension was worse than before. Finally,
one night as they were standing at the kitchen sink
doing the dishes, one broke out in the nursery songs
of their childhood. The other joined in. They sang
their common poetry in German and the language and
lyrics of that moment rekindled a bond that they
hadn't been able to otherwise find in plain speech.
Since that time, the two sisters spoken German,
their first and native language, whenever they have
reunited and their relationship has vastly improved.
Poetry is humankind's first
native language. Once the printing press was invented
in 1440 and words could be recorded, poetry no longer
carried the news of the day. Longer forms like the
novel and the memoir could be developed and reproduced.
Drama could be written down, actors no longer needing
the aid of poetry to help them remember their lines.
Now we have the internet, fax machines, cell phones,
and CNN to carry our news, deliver our messages,
and link together our diverse culture. Old fashioned
storytelling has been replaced by television and
film.
But the element of poetry
that will never be replaced by the media remains:
the ability to capture emotion, thought or idea
with a primitive, spooky, chill-up-your-spine force.
The great German medieval mystic Hildegard of Bingen
thought real spirituality rested in the creative
moment when art was born. A poet, composer, painter,
musician, Hildegard made art the transforming center
of her life. On a day to day level, it made life
worth living. On a mystical level, it brought her
in contact with a power of a higher realm. What
mattered for Hildegard was the act of creation.
Poetry led her to her visions, the painting of her
mandalas that illustrate her depiction of the cosmos:
all things in one and one in all.
Today, our vision of the
world is all too easily reduced to the mundane.
Another trip to the mall accomplished on the way
home from work, another child carted to soccer practice.
The practice of poetry allows those small moments
to resonate in a larger way to create a more encompassing
view of existence. Elizabeth Bishop's "The Waiting
Room," captures a young girl's trip to the dentist
with her aunt. We see the ordinary dentist's office.
We hear the aunt's expected moan in pain. Yet the
portrait of a girl reading the National Geographic
magazine while she waits transports us to another
continent, into the world of adventure and imagination.
While few of us may have
the cosmic vision of Hildegard, while few of us
may be reunited with a sibling after living through
a holocaust, we can widen our world by recognizing
and embracing our own poetic moments. Buddhists
call this practice mindfulness. Staying in and appreciating
the beauty of the here and now, and allowing the
present to remind us of the greater mysteries of
the universe. What scares most people about poetry
is abstraction. The most common public misconception
is that poetry is written in obscure language about
an obscure subject to convey esoteric ideas that
will never be grasped by regular people. Great poetry
does the opposite. It begins with the specific,
concrete incident or idea to make the leap toward
a shared truth.
Please don't let me leave
you with the idea that poetry is just a feel-good
exercise that might come in handy in a crisis. Poetry
is revolutionary. Poetry is electric. After all,
why hadn't the farm woman in Clear Lake heard
of Elizabeth Bishop? What hadn't the girl
in Burlington been able to speak in class? I don't
pretend to know the circumstances behind those two
women's lives, but historically women, especially
rural women, have been denied the educational privileges
of men. Historically, women have been discouraged
from finding their voices, expressing themselves
in the classroom, speaking up anywhere, lest they
appear smarter than men. For the woman in the blue
dress and the girl in pigtails poetry was emancipating.
It wasn't until the latter
half of the twentieth century that women, people
of color, people of various sexual orientations
and the disabled were finally allowed to find their
voices. In poetry or elsewhere. Poetry has become
a road to self-actualization for many individuals,
many groups. I think of voices like those of Adrienne
Rich, Audre Lorde, Ray Young Bear, Ray Gonzalez,
and Li-Young Lee that may have been lost or silenced
in previous eras. With the dawning of the new millennium,
we're living in an age with one foot firmly planted
in the land of social constraints, prejudice and
scapegoating, and one foot moving through the door
of higher consciousness. Let's let poetry keep pushing
us forward.
|

"Sometimes,
I think that we, the reading public, so often
hear that adage that no one really cares about
poetry that we begin to believe it ourselves.
And while I do think it takes some serious study
to be able to appreciate all the nuances and allusions
of a complicated text, it is good to remind myself,
that a group of farm women in northern Iowa can
nail the heart and basic meaning of a poem just
as well as the most schooled critics."
--Mary Swander
Iowa poet laureate
|