Manuscript Review Page
On-line reviews of articles submitted to Iowa Journal of Cultural Studies will be conducted by reviewers selected from and by our editorial board. Submissions undergoing review will be accessible only to approved reviewers. Reviews will be electronically submitted to the journal editors. Reviewers' comments will be compiled and forwarded to the author electronically.

 

Reviewer's Name  
Reviewer's Email Address  
Article Number and Title  

 

1. Argument

   
Argument Summary  
Article Argument Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments  

 

2. Introduction

   
Article introduction Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments

 

3. Literature Review and Theoretical Methodology

A. Thorough and Appropriate Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments
B. Research or Theory reviewed and critiqued in article Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments
C. Organization Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments

 

4. Critical Innovations

 
A. Conclusions clear and logical Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments
B. Practical Innovations Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
Comments
5. Writing Style, Grammar, MLA Format Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
 
6. Illustrations Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions Unacceptable Does not apply
 
7. Written Feedback to the Author  
 
8. Recommendation for IJCS Accept Accept with minor revisions Accept with major revisions - revise, rewrite, resubmit Reject - unsound Reject - inappropriate for this special issue, other journals suggested